Gingerbread Philosophy

“The great gingerbread war has heated up in San Francisco, and it all comes down to one eternal question: Is it a gingerbread house if you can’t eat it?” So asked an article in the Chronicle newspaper a few years ago. Just as I also wondered this morning, when I heard from two young women who for years have used a hot glue gun to put theirs together. I had never heard of such a thing. Their children have started asking when they can eat the house, and the mothers remind them that they always only eat loose candy while they are assembling it.

At our house, we’ve had two gingerbread construction events that I can remember. I wasn’t the instigator. I prefer to provide background support in the form of dishwashing and photography, because cake and icing have always seemed like the most unlikely media for art or architecture, and near certain failure doesn’t sound like fun.

These first photos are from 25 + years ago, when young people could do things solely for fun without having to spend time on their phones taking pictures to share worldwide. My kids and their friends were making two houses, and one never would stay standing. I think the siding was hopelessly warped from being baked on a thin cookie sheet.

In San Francisco, it’s been traditional for the chefs at the Fairmont Hotel to make their large Christmas gingerbread house (top picture) out of completely edible components. Because a gingerbread house is the last thing that should be purely symbolic, right? When my friends and I had a tradition for a few years, of a trip to San Francisco at Christmastime, we appreciated being able to break off pieces of the house to eat. Nibbling was discouraged, true, but every day the house was quietly repaired, and sometimes a repairman chef would hand a child a piece of candy from his kit in hopes that it might mean one less candy cane broken off.

“Go ahead, have a piece,” said Tom Klein, Fairmont hotel’s regional vice president and general manager. He was handing out gingerbread shingles to startled hotel guests in the lobby. Technically, eating the Fairmont’s walk-through gingerbread house is not allowed, but Klein had a point to make about the edibility of the building materials, and the kids he was handing the gingerbread to were not complaining.

“Meanwhile, at the St. Francis, its fanciful baked house was more of a medieval castle, lavishly and intricately decorated by chefs with tweezers. It’s a smaller, more intricate creation, exhibited behind a sturdy metal fence designed to keep grubby little fingers at bay.”

I have seen the St. Francis castle, too, but I don’t  think I knew that it was gingerbread. I read that they recycle the gingerbread from previous houses to make it; that would seem to make it inedible right there. On the other hand, I liked getting a whiff of the Fairmont gingerbread:

I’m not saying that the mothers mentioned above were aiming for Instagram perfection. Probably they just feel the way I do about my Christmas cookies; I enjoy the creative project and like doing it alone. And if a recipe calls for a really messy or difficult ingredient, I just won’t use it. That’s why I don’t make gingerbread houses. Even the most precise and well thought out ones, with slabs of sturdy cake baked on unwarped cookie sheets, must be accepted as “the best we could do with the materials.” Here are my pictures of the more recent one built in my house, spearheaded by Pippin and the Professor.

This year the gingerbread house at the Fairmont is bigger than ever, and you may rent it for “private” dining. Up to ten people can sit at table inside, starting at $300 for two hours. I’m really curious about who will be enjoying that luxury. (It doesn’t sound appealing to me, to be on display to every holiday gawker passing through the opulent lobby, while partaking of such a gimmick.) The population of San Francisco is notoriously low on children, but maybe some well-to-do ladies will stop by with their grandchildren on the way back from seeing “The Nutcracker.”

I do love everything about edible gingerbread houses — their colorful and aromatic, candy-laden selves, and their fairy-tale connections — as long as other people are building them. How unlikely! How extravagant and wild. My style is to let the people get old enough to want to try culinary architecture on their own, and to have the patience to see the project through to the end; until then, I’m happy to make a mess in the kitchen with children of any age, baking gingerbread cookies. And when they’ve had enough of that, and run off after a while, I will also love finishing up on my own!

From this house, what I’d like is a few puffs of malt-ball smoke. ❤

8 thoughts on “Gingerbread Philosophy

  1. What a delightful post! Gingerbread houses have not been part of the Christmas tradition I grew up with. My daughter married into a South African German family for whom the baking of such houses are entrenched over generations. It has been interesting for me to observe the care with which these are constructed, and I note that one can now purchase baking kits to make the task easier.

    Liked by 1 person

  2. We used to have a neighbour who created a gingerbread street with gingerbread houses on a long table in the basement. He took weeks to make it ( I have no idea if his family ended up eating it or not). But it was impressive to see. We didn’t do gingerbread houses with our children but when Kate, the oldest grand was in her teens she decided that she and the others should each make one. I was not about to bake all the required walls etc. and neither were any of the parents so my DH built each one a sturdy plywood house and they had fun decorating them. I know it wasn’t authentic gingerbread but it made my life easier.
    On the subject of life being easier, are you seeing an end to all the construction and remodeling yet?

    Liked by 1 person

  3. There’s a nearby resort and conference center that always has a huge gingerbread house in their atrium. I’ve never been to see it, since gingerbread houses hold no interest for me. Of course, it they’d been part of our Christmas traditions, it would be different. Beyond that, I’ve been invited to sample two homemade gingerbread houses, and would far prefer one of your ginger cookies to those stale, tough walls and overly-sweet decorations!

    The kits do seem to be popular, though. Every year I see more of them in the stores.

    Liked by 1 person

  4. I’m with you – the whole process seems quite impossible to me. That may be due to seeing too many pictures of perfect-looking g. houses, I don’t know. But it terrifies me. I also agree with your opinions of that large one you can rent – what the…? 😉

    Liked by 1 person

  5. I would never dare nibble on a gingerbread house! The story of Hansel and Gretel always terrified me! However, I love anything gingerbread for Christmas. Our granddaughters make houses every year, but I don’t think they eat them. Or maybe, they do. I will find out! What a delightful post!

    Liked by 1 person

Leave a comment

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.